Start free
Home › Guides › Spreadsheet vs catalog
Comparison

Spreadsheet vs drive catalog

A spreadsheet is where most drive tracking starts — and where most of it quietly dies. Here is an honest look at both.

Updated November 7, 2026 · 2 min read

Where the spreadsheet works

Where it breaks

Search results across drives, down to individual files
A catalog answers “which drive has this file?” — a spreadsheet can’t.

Side by side

SpreadsheetScanned catalog
File-level detailOnly what you typeEvery file name
Stays currentManualRescan when it changes
Link from drive to entryHandwritten IDQR sticker
Phone accessAwkwardBuilt in
Guests without accountsLink sharingTeam PIN, read-only
CostFreeSubscription

Keep both, if you like

Many teams keep the spreadsheet for purchase and warranty info and let the catalog handle contents. Where’s My Drive exports everything to CSV, so the two can live side by side.

Migrating from a spreadsheet without losing anything

  1. Keep the spreadsheet — it holds things only people know (purchase date, warranty, owner).
  2. Give every row a drive ID if it does not already have one, and write that ID on the physical drive.
  3. Scan each drive into the catalog under the same ID. Copy anything important from the row into the drive’s note.
  4. Replace the “contents” column in the spreadsheet with a link to the catalog — or drop it.

What people usually discover

The first scan of a “known” drive almost always turns up surprises: projects nobody listed, duplicates of other drives, folders with tens of gigabytes of cache. That alone tends to free space — and it is a good sign the spreadsheet was describing what someone hoped was on the drive, not what is.

Label your first drive tonight

14-day free trial, no card. Connect a drive once, print its QR label, and scan it from any phone to see every file — even when the drive is unplugged.

Frequently asked questions

Is a spreadsheet good enough to track hard drives?

For a few drives with stable contents, yes. It breaks when you need to find individual files or when contents change often.

Can I export a drive catalog to a spreadsheet?

Yes — Where’s My Drive exports every drive, folder and file to CSV.

A studio archive shelf of external drives, RAID enclosures and cases

Scan the label. See the drive.

14 days free, no card. Connect your messiest drive tonight, stick its QR label on, and scan it from your phone tomorrow.